VIDEO

Retiring With a 401(k)? Don't Roll It Over Until You Know These Rules

Should You Roll Your 401(k) Into an IRA When You Retire?

Rolling a 401(k) into an IRA is common at retirement, and there can be good reasons to do it. But retiring doesn't automatically mean you should roll over your account. Depending on your age, investments, and plan rules, you could give up valuable benefits that are difficult to recover.

In this video, we walk through five things to check before you roll over a 401(k): whether you're retiring before 59½, what you're actually paying, whether you own company stock in the plan, what features you'd lose, and how creditor protection works. The better question isn't whether to roll over. It's what you're gaining and what you're giving up.

Quick answer: A rollover can make sense, but it isn't automatic. Before moving a 401(k) at retirement, check five things: early-withdrawal access before age 59½ (including the Rule of 55), total costs, company stock and net unrealized appreciation (NUA), plan features you'd lose, and creditor protection. Some of these opportunities can be hard to recover once the money is in an IRA.

Check 1: Are You Retiring Before Age 59½?

There's an exception called the Rule of 55. If you leave your employer during or after the year you turn 55, withdrawals from that employer's 401(k) can avoid the usual 10% early-withdrawal penalty. Ordinary income tax may still apply, and the exception generally applies to the plan of the employer you just left, not to accounts from earlier jobs. One planning tip: if you roll old 401(k)s into your current employer's plan before you leave, that money is generally covered by the Rule of 55 too, as long as the plan accepts roll-ins.

That exception doesn't apply to an IRA. Let's say you retire at 56 and roll your entire 401(k) into an IRA. You could find out you just gave up the penalty-free access you were counting on until age 59½.

Illustrative example only. The Rule of 55 depends on your plan's rules and your individual situation. Consult your tax advisor.

Key insight: It doesn't have to be all or nothing. If your plan allows it, you may be able to leave enough in the 401(k) to cover withdrawals until age 59½ and roll over the rest. Just check how your plan handles withdrawals first, because some plans only allow a full lump sum or fixed installments.

Check 2: What Are You Actually Paying?

Here's an assumption worth testing: "An IRA will automatically be cheaper." Maybe. Maybe not. Some large employer plans have access to low-cost institutional funds that are hard to match on your own, while other 401(k)s have higher administrative costs or limited choices.

Pull out your 401(k) fee disclosure and look at the investment expenses and administrative fees. Then add up what you'd pay in the IRA, including any advisory fees you'd pay after the rollover. Compare the total cost, not just the investment fees. Don't assume. Compare.

Check 3: Do You Own Company Stock in the Plan?

This one can have major tax implications. If your 401(k) holds highly appreciated company stock, look into a strategy called net unrealized appreciation, or NUA.

Consider someone whose company stock is worth $400,000, with a cost basis of just $50,000. If you qualify for NUA, you may be able to pay ordinary income tax on the $50,000 cost basis when the shares are distributed, while the $350,000 of appreciation could qualify for long-term capital gains rates when you sell. If you're under 59½, the 10% early-withdrawal penalty may also apply to the cost basis unless an exception, like the Rule of 55, applies. Roll that stock into an IRA, and every dollar eventually comes out taxed as ordinary income.

Illustrative example only. Actual tax results depend on plan rules, timing, and individual circumstances. Consult your tax advisor.

NUA has strict requirements, including a qualifying event and an eligible lump-sum distribution of the entire balance from the employer's plans of the same type within one tax year. That doesn't mean the whole account has to be cashed out. The rest of the account, other than the company stock, can generally still be rolled into an IRA as part of that distribution. It isn't right for everyone. But once those shares are rolled into an IRA, the NUA opportunity for those shares is generally lost. That's why it's important to check NUA before completing a rollover. NUA is also Mistake 6 in our video on 7 retirement account mistakes you can't undo.

Check 4: What Features Would You Lose?

Your 401(k) may hold investments you can't get in the same form outside the plan, like institutional share classes or stable-value funds.

Check how the plan handles withdrawals, too. Some 401(k)s only allow a full lump sum or fixed installments, which can make retirement income clunky and can limit a partial-withdrawal strategy for early retirees. That's one area where an IRA is often more flexible.

An IRA usually gives you a much broader investment universe. That can be a real advantage. But broader isn't automatically better. So ask: is there anything in this plan I actually want to keep, and what would replace it in the IRA?

Check 5: Don't Overlook Creditor Protection

There's a legal difference people don't think about. Most 401(k)s are protected from creditors under a federal law called ERISA.

IRAs have protections too, but they aren't identical. In bankruptcy, money rolled over from a 401(k) generally keeps strong federal protection. Outside of bankruptcy, IRA protection depends on your state.

This may not be the deciding factor for everyone. But if creditor protection matters in your situation, say you're a business owner or in a high-liability profession, talk to an attorney before moving a large account.

So When Does an IRA Make Sense?

An IRA can have real advantages: more investment choices, the ability to consolidate several old accounts into one, and more flexibility with withdrawals. And later on, qualified charitable distributions (QCDs) can be another advantage. Starting at age 70½, eligible IRA owners can make direct transfers to qualified charities, potentially excluding those distributions from taxable income. QCDs generally aren't available directly from a 401(k).

The point isn't that a 401(k) is better, or that an IRA is better. It's that you should know what you're giving up before you move the money.

If You Do Roll Over: Use a Direct Rollover

If you decide to roll it over, use a direct rollover so the money moves straight to your IRA. That avoids the mandatory 20% federal withholding that generally applies when eligible rollover money is paid to you. A rollover should solve a problem. It shouldn't happen just because you retired.

Planning takeaway: Before moving a 401(k) at retirement, compare what you'd gain with what you'd give up. Check early-withdrawal access, total costs, company stock, plan features, and creditor protection. Because this decision can involve tax and legal considerations, review it with your financial advisor, your tax professional, and, if creditor protection matters, an attorney.

Coordinating a rollover with the rest of your tax picture is an important part of retirement tax planning.

Frequently Asked Questions About Rolling Over a 401(k) at Retirement

Should you roll your 401(k) into an IRA when you retire?

Not automatically. Rolling a 401(k) into an IRA is common at retirement, and there can be good reasons to do it, such as more investment choices, the ability to consolidate old accounts, and more flexibility with withdrawals. But depending on your age, your investments, and your plan, you may give up benefits that are hard to get back. Before you decide, compare what you'd gain and what you'd give up, including penalty-free access before age 59½, total costs, company stock, plan features, and creditor protection.

What is the Rule of 55, and does it apply to an IRA?

The Rule of 55 can let you avoid the usual 10% early-withdrawal penalty on withdrawals from an employer's 401(k) if you leave that employer during or after the year you turn 55. Ordinary income tax may still apply. The exception generally applies to the plan of the employer you just left, and it doesn't apply to an IRA. Money from older 401(k)s that you roll into your current employer's plan before leaving is generally covered too, if the plan accepts roll-ins. If you roll that 401(k) into an IRA, the 10% additional tax generally applies to withdrawals before age 59½ unless another exception applies.

Can you roll over only part of your 401(k)?

It may be possible. If your plan allows it, you may be able to leave enough in the 401(k) to cover withdrawals until age 59½ and roll over the rest. Plan rules vary, though. Some 401(k)s only allow a full lump sum or fixed installments, which can limit this approach, so check how your plan handles withdrawals before you move any money.

Is an IRA cheaper than a 401(k)?

Not necessarily. Some large employer plans have access to low-cost institutional funds that are hard to match on your own, while other 401(k)s have higher administrative costs or limited investment choices. To compare, review your 401(k) fee disclosure, including investment expenses and administrative fees, and compare the total cost with what you'd pay in the IRA, including any advisory fees. The U.S. Department of Labor also lists differences in expenses, available investments, services, and distribution options as factors to consider before a rollover.

What is NUA, and why check it before rolling over company stock?

Net unrealized appreciation, or NUA, is a tax strategy for highly appreciated company stock held in a 401(k). If you qualify, you may be able to pay ordinary income tax on the stock's cost basis when the shares are distributed, while the appreciation could qualify for long-term capital gains rates when you sell. If you're under 59½, the 10% penalty may also apply to the cost basis unless an exception applies. In an illustrative example with stock worth $400,000 and a cost basis of $50,000, the $350,000 of appreciation could qualify for capital gains treatment. NUA has strict requirements, including a qualifying event and an eligible lump-sum distribution of the entire balance from the employer's plans of the same type within one tax year. The rest of the account, other than the company stock, can generally still be rolled into an IRA as part of that distribution. It isn't right for everyone. Once the shares are rolled into an IRA, the NUA opportunity for those shares is generally lost, so check NUA before you roll over.

What features might you lose by rolling a 401(k) into an IRA?

Your 401(k) may hold investments you can't get in the same form outside the plan, like institutional share classes or stable-value funds. It may also come with the Rule of 55 exception and federal creditor protection under ERISA, both of which can change after a rollover. An IRA usually offers a broader investment universe and often more flexible withdrawals, but broader isn't automatically better. Ask what you'd want to keep and what would replace it.

Are 401(k)s better protected from creditors than IRAs?

Most 401(k)s are protected from creditors under a federal law called ERISA. IRAs have protections too, but they aren't identical. In bankruptcy, money rolled over from a 401(k) generally keeps strong federal protection. Outside of bankruptcy, IRA protection depends on your state. For most people this won't be the deciding factor, but if creditor protection matters in your situation, such as for a business owner or someone in a high-liability profession, talk to an attorney before moving a large account.

What is a direct rollover, and why does it matter?

In a direct rollover, the money moves straight from your 401(k) to your IRA instead of being paid to you first. That avoids the mandatory 20% federal withholding that generally applies when eligible rollover money is paid directly to you. If you decide to roll over, a direct rollover is usually the cleaner way to do it.

Want a Clear Picture of Your Retirement Readiness?

Take our free Retirement Readiness Assessment. It takes less than a minute and gives you a high-level view of your retirement readiness across income, investments, taxes, healthcare, and overall planning.

Start the Assessment

Investment advice is offered through Bayntree Wealth Advisors, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. Insurance and annuity products are offered separately through Bayntree Planning Group, LLC. Bayntree does not provide, and no statement contained herein shall constitute, tax or legal advice. You should consult a tax or legal professional on any such matters. Opinions expressed herein are solely those of Bayntree Wealth Advisors. All content is for informational purposes only and is not intended to provide the basis for any financial decisions.

As Featured In

The Wall Street Journal Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Forbes Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
CNBC Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
The Washington Post Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Yahoo Finance Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
MarketWatch Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Personal Finance
Retirement Planning