VIDEO

Inherited an IRA? Don’t Make This Tax Mistake

What Is the Biggest Tax Mistake People Make With an Inherited IRA?

The most expensive inherited IRA mistake is withdrawing the entire account at once. Because traditional IRA distributions are taxed as ordinary income, a large withdrawal in one year can push you into a higher tax bracket and create a significant tax bill.

Non-spouse beneficiaries usually have up to ten years to withdraw inherited IRA funds under current rules. Spreading withdrawals over several years allows you to coordinate distributions with your income and potentially reduce the overall tax impact.

Example: A 44-year-old woman inherited a $250,000 IRA and moved the entire account to her savings account. Because the distribution counted as ordinary income it created a tax bill of more than $60,000. With a better strategy much of that tax could have been reduced or delayed.

Why This Inherited IRA Mistake Happens

Common Misunderstanding What Actually Happens Better Approach
Moving the IRA to your bank account is harmless The moment funds leave the IRA they become taxable income. Keep the money inside an Inherited IRA.
Inherited IRA withdrawals have penalties There is no 10 percent early withdrawal penalty. The distribution is still fully taxable.
Taking the money immediately is simplest A full withdrawal can push you into a higher tax bracket. Spread distributions across multiple years when possible.
You can fix the mistake later Once the funds leave the IRA and 60 days pass the tax event cannot be undone. Talk to an advisor before moving inherited retirement assets.

The Smarter Way to Handle an Inherited IRA

Under current SECURE Act rules most non-spouse beneficiaries must withdraw the account within ten years. That does not mean you must withdraw everything immediately. Strategic withdrawals allow you to control taxes and potentially keep yourself in lower brackets.

Example strategy: Instead of withdrawing $250,000 in one year spreading distributions such as $25,000 per year over ten years may significantly reduce total taxes depending on your income.

Ways to Reduce Taxes After a Large IRA Distribution

If a large inherited IRA withdrawal already occurred the tax event usually cannot be reversed. However several strategies may help soften the impact in that tax year.

  • Maximize contributions to retirement plans such as a 401(k), SEP IRA, or Solo 401(k).
  • Fund a Health Savings Account if eligible.
  • Use a donor-advised fund for charitable giving.
  • Harvest investment losses to offset gains.
  • Coordinate deductions if you have business income.
Key lesson: The most expensive financial mistakes are often not bad investments. They are uncoordinated decisions involving taxes, timing, and withdrawals.

Quick Self Check Before Moving Money From an Inherited IRA

  • Have I opened an Inherited IRA instead of transferring funds to my bank?
  • Do I understand the ten-year distribution rule?
  • Have I projected the tax impact of withdrawals?
  • Am I coordinating distributions with my annual income?
  • Have I spoken with a financial advisor or tax professional first?

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you pay taxes when you inherit an IRA?

Yes. Traditional IRA distributions are taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn. The original contributions were tax-deferred so taxes are due when beneficiaries take distributions.

Do inherited IRAs have the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty?

No. Beneficiaries generally do not pay the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty. However the withdrawal is still taxable income.

How long do you have to withdraw money from an inherited IRA?

Most non-spouse beneficiaries must withdraw the entire account within ten years under SECURE Act rules although withdrawals can often be spread out during that period.

Can an inherited IRA distribution be reversed?

In most cases no. Once funds leave the IRA and the 60-day rollover window has passed the distribution is taxable and cannot be undone.

Should you talk to an advisor before withdrawing an inherited IRA?

Yes. A coordinated withdrawal strategy can reduce taxes and prevent costly mistakes.

Want to See How Coordinated Your Retirement Plan Is?

Take our free Retirement Readiness Assessment. It takes about a minute and highlights potential gaps across income, taxes, investments, healthcare, and overall planning.

Take the Retirement Readiness Assessment

As Featured In

The Wall Street Journal Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Forbes Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
CNBC Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
The Washington Post Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Yahoo Finance Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
MarketWatch Logo in Bayntree Wealth Advisors Blue, Scottsdale, Arizona.
Taxes
Retirement Planning